Lately the “Money Merge Account” software program- or MMA- offered by United First Financial has been getting a fair amount of press and interest. As the author of a Blog titled “Homequitybuilder”, I did want to relay a few of my thoughts on the matter. But first, a few disclaimers-
1. I am biased. As you can read elsewhere here on this Blog, and also on my related website- www.homequitybuilder.info - I am the proprietor of an equity-accelerating “competitor” of sorts, called the Alternative Mortgage Fund. The AMF is not yet commercially available, as no working agreement has been reached with a lender. But the AMF is a mortgage product in the works that I’ve developed.
2. I am not an expert in all things “MMA”, or “offset mortgages” or the like. I also do not have an advanced degree in finance. I am “just” a mortgage loan officer.
That all being said, the first thing I would say is that the MMA program is NOT a “scam”. Some have called it such, for a variety of reasons. UFF is selling the MMA program/software via a national and growing MLM (multiple level marketing) campaign, and there are some who associate any MLM offering with a scam. MLM may not be my cup of tea really, but it certainly is not a scam in and of itself. There are others who call it a scam because of the relatively hefty asking price for the MMA program (about $3500 retail), when if a borrower was financially astute enough they could go about all the noted equity appreciation without the help of the MMA product. However, I don’t believe that renders it a scam either. It is a product that could (and does) help a bunch of people pay off or down their mortgage faster, and I’m a big fan of that outcome.
The $3500 price tag I have to say is another matter though. Already, if you do a Google search, you’ll find a handful of other equity-building HELOC (home equity line of credit) programs that are all very similar if not identical. They are being offered by a few different companies. I understand that one is called the “Equity Genie” and it sells for about HALF of the MMA price. There is another, called MaxMyMortgage(?), that sells for just $99 total. If there are CD-roms/programs that do the same for a $99 price tag, why would anyone pay $3,500 for it? I don’t know, but I can tell you that the group at MMA/ UFF have a very good marketing/PR campaign that ties in with their MLM offering and fee/income structure. A lot of loan officers (and others) are pitching the MMA and are earning a fair amount of money doing it.
For the numbers and who exactly can benefit from an MMA type program, this is what I’ve come up with thus far (feel free to verify/clarify this with those specific firms)-
1. Credit score of at least 680 (this eliminates about half of the borrowing public)
2. Equity in their home of atleast 25% (ex: house is woth $500K and there’s a mortgage on it for $400K. $100K in equity); this eliminates about half of the remaining half of consumers
3. Positive monthly cash flow/ discretionary monthly income of at least $150/month. Obviously the more the better.
If you fall in line with all 3 criteria, and are willing to abide by the program and the fiscal recommendations, then the MMA- or any of its like-competitors- can and will pay off your mortgage much faster than normal. In the example I was handed by UFF, they show cutting 16 years off a 30 year mortgage. I’d have to say that’s pretty darn good.
There are some “big picture” problems that I see with the expansion of the MMA-type products in the USA (the basis of these programs started in New Zealand, then the UK, and about 5 years ago it started in earnest in the USA). In no particular order:
1. The vehicle for much of the program is obtaining a HELOC, and using the $$ in the HELOC to pay for your non-housing monthly (and periodic/sporadic) expenses. Like car payments, utility bills, car insurance, whatever. Of course none of these items is what a HELOC is truly to be used for. Most HELOCs, if you read all that fine print, are to be used only for making improvements to your physical house/property. If you’re not doing that at all, I’d say there could be a chance of some issues or liability (but I’d also admit I’m not an attorney).
2. The bigger issue is that of loan servicing and also of the mortgage-securities market on Wall Street. I’m quite certain that the servicing (collecting and depositing payments, paperwork and accounting) of the MMA-based mortgage are going to be more timely and more expensive. Who’s going to pay for those extra costs? The bank or 3rd party servicer won’t be paying that. Somehow it will be charged or billed back to borrower- in increased fees or something else.
More importantly, what investment group (Merrill Lynch, etc) that purchases thousands of mortgage notes is going to want to purchase many notes where the borrower is going to pay off the mortgage completely in half the time? Or maybe even 1/3 the time? The individial investors that buy these mortgage-backed securities (stocks) are assuming a very small amount of people will prepay their mortgages. When someone does prepay early, the overall value of that MBS/stock is actually less, because they are earning less interest/return on that mortgage. If this is the case, that will mean that companies like Merrill Lynch will be less likely or will halt buying groups of mortgages that include hefty prepayment characteristics like the MMA provides. If less firms will buy all these mortgages from the various wholesale and other lenders other there, then either the lenders will stop allowing people to use the MMA with their mortgages, or maybe the mortgage rate will be higher to accomodate for these potential issues.
A lot of this is merely speculation on my part, but be sure that the banks and those on Wall Street are (generally) pretty bright. If they see some niche out there that is weakening their profits, they are likely going to do something to “fight back” and maintain their bottom line.
As for my bottom line on this subject, I have no real gripes against what the MMA does and what it can do for some borrowers. I only advise that all interested do their own due diligence on the MMA and other programs. It might be for you, and maybe you’ll be the one smiling in 10 or 12 years with no more mortgage payments….